Mellowly

How long does a sleep playlist need to be?

Longer than your night. Measure from pressing play to your alarm, then add half an hour. For most people that is eight to nine hours — about four times longer than the sleep playlists most apps suggest.

If you have ever been woken at four in the morning by music that was not the music you put on, this page explains what happened and how to stop it happening again.

Work out your number

Your night, in hours

—

Set your two times above.

The sums are done in your browser. Nothing is sent anywhere and nothing is stored.

What actually wakes you

The playlist ends, and the app chooses what happens next

When a playlist runs out, Spotify's Autoplay keeps the sound going by starting songs it thinks are similar. It is a sensible feature for the afternoon and a poor one at 4am, because "similar" is a guess made by a machine that cannot hear how loud the result is.

What arrives next is a different artist, mastered to a different level, possibly with drums, a vocal, or a build. Nothing got louder on purpose. It simply stopped being the music you chose — and that change is what surfaces a sleeping person, not volume on its own.

The same thing happens on a two-hour album, a six-hour video that ends, or a playlist you have had on repeat with Autoplay left on. The length of the night is fixed. The only variable you control is whether your music outlasts it.

A sleep timer solves the opposite problem

Timers stop the music. That is exactly right if you want help falling asleep and silence after — and exactly wrong if you want sound all night, because sudden silence wakes a light sleeper as readily as sudden sound. Spotify's timer also stops at one hour, so it cannot cover a night even if you wanted it to.

Repeat works, with one cost

Looping a playlist you already like is reliable, free, and keeps you inside music you picked. The cost is that you hear the same opening tracks again around dawn, during the lightest part of your sleep, which is when you are most likely to notice. A playlist longer than your night avoids that without relying on any setting staying switched on.

Two minutes, once

Turn Autoplay off

Worth doing whatever you listen to. It stops anything being appended to the end of what you chose.

  1. On your phone: tap your profile picture, then Settings and privacy.
  2. Open Playback, scroll to Autoplay, and switch it off.
  3. On a computer: profile picture → Settings, then switch off Autoplay similar songs when your music ends.
  4. While you are there, turn off Smart Shuffle and Enhance too — both add songs you did not choose.

With Autoplay off, a short playlist no longer wakes you — it goes quiet instead. Which is why length still matters.

If you would rather not build one

Nine playlists, each long enough for a night

This is what I make. Every playlist runs past nine hours, every track fades into the next so there are no gaps to surface through, and there are no lyrics and no drums anywhere in the 223 tracks. Free, and there is nothing to sign up to.

I started making these because a playlist ran out on me at 7:48 one morning and something with a drum kit in it took over. Everything here is built so that cannot happen.